About ECLIPSE: Is Jacob right about Edward manipulating Bella? Is he really NOT as perfect as he seems?[pg594]

First off, Eclipse was amazing! I have loved Jacob since Twilight so of course I want to believe him, but I also want to trust Edward. I do think that there was something about Tonya (that vampire he stayed with in New Moon). I think that was the one who wanted him. I think there's more to that story then what's been told to Bella.